Roughly 14,678 of thosekillings were solved or received some sort of closure as time passed, leaving around 6,546 murders unsolved in New Jerseyalone today. On March 1, 1932, famed aviator Charles Lindberghdiscovered his 20-month-old son missing from hissecond-story bedroom of their Hopewell home and a ransom note on the window sill. A $10,000 reward still stands for information on Mitten's death. Landis went on to develop Sea Isle City and died in 1900 at the age of 67. Thank you! Musicians Bon Jovi, Whitney Houston and Paul Simon, Hollywood star Bruce Willis as well as American politician Cory Booker are a few distinguished personalities from New Jersey. A search of her home revealed her telephone wires were cut, and her bed sheets and comforter were missing. Lockey Mitten, 65, was found stabbed to deathin her Williamstown mobile home on July 28, 2007. KOMIN. The 69-year-old, who is also known as Assata Shakur, remains on FBI's most wanted terrorist list with a $2 million reward for her capture and return. Lisa McBride, 27, was last seen alive after entering her Highland Lakes home alone at 2 a.m. on June 23, 1990 after attending a concert in New York with three friends, authorities said. (Marisa Iati | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com). His final victims were the pharmacist and the man's wife and mother, after which Unruh returned home. Many local, county, and state law enforcement websites as well as Project: Cold Cases unsolved homicide database include profiles of unsolved murders in New Jersey. You'll receive your first newsletter soon! Cifelli and Jenin had alibis. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). Amber Hagerman. Cookie Settings/Do Not Sell My Personal Information. Investigators in the field near the spot where Jane Durrua's body was found in 1968 in East Keansburg. Additionally, people with information may contact Crime Stoppers of Middlesex County Inc. at its website,middlesextips.com. We believe the more resources we can provide to digital volunteers and citizen solvers mean more citizen detective communities. Kallinger died after a seizure at the State Correctional Institute at Cresson, Pa., in 1996, at the age of 59. famous murders in new jersey. Nancy Nogas murder in 1999, Michael Conways murder in 2011, Daniel Gravess murder in 2013, and Quiana Deess murder in 1992 are just a few of the many cases where Trentonmurders DNA, as well as DNAfrom crimes in other parts of New Jersey, has been used to solve or introduce new information or evidenceto cold cases. He got his nickname after he dismembered his two victims and set the torsos on fire. Greg Staffordsmith of the Lakewood Township Police Department, Detective Bureau at 732-363-0200, ext. Chesimard was also convicted of first-degree murderbut in 1979 escaped from the New Jersey State Reformatory for Women at Clinton and resurfaced a few years later in Cuba, where she still lives. The stereotype of the buttoned-up neighbor who explodes in violence has roots in one of America's earliest mass murders. And they also learned Marshall was heavily in debt and had been carrying on an affair with a woman to whom he had discussed "getting rid of" his wife. Mark Himebaugh, 11, was last seen around 4 p.m. on Nov. 25, 1991 bya security guard at Cape May County Park South, who reported the boywas walking with a girl. Investigators released a sketch of a suspect in the killing of Bruce Santos. Charles Cullen, an ICU nurse who preferred night shifts, worked at 10 hospitals and health care centers for16 years before he fell under suspicion of delivering fatal doses of drugs to his patients. (AP file photo). His widow, Anna, was never convinced of his guilt (many still aren't) and spent nearly60 yearspetitioning the state to reopen the case. Megan Kanka, 7, of Hamilton Township, was sexually assaulted and murdered by a twice-convicted sex offender. The 1935 trial resulted in Hauptmann's conviction, based largely on circumstantial evidence. Neighbors told the Wall Street Journal that Davis' diatribes at council meetings.were a fixture in town politics for more than a decade as she often spoke out against privatizing municipal services and using public funds for business development. famous murders in new jersey. Police then lobbed tear gas into the house and Unruh surrendered, telling them, "I'd have killed a thousand if I'd had bullets enough." Kuklinski was captured after investigators linked him to several unsolved homicides, and an undercover federal agent posing as another hit man got close to him and sold Kuklinski what he claimed was pure cyanide. There, Marshall claimed, he was checking his tire when he was knocked unconscious and a man shot and killed his wife on whom, police soon discovered, he had taken out a $1.5 million insurance policy. He would later die in prison. Zachary Latham, 18, is charged with manslaughter in the killing of William Durham in South Jersey. There are several publicly available resources that share the number of murders in New Jersey by year within crime reports filled with statistics, including those provided by local, state, and federal law enforcement agencies, as well as Project: Cold Case and the Murder Accountability Project. The cold case of Leroy Julious, Cops crack cold case armed robbery after accomplice comes forward. Werner Foerster was killed in 1973 after a shootout on the New Jersey Turnpike. Newark housewife Mary Frances Creighton was called the Lucrezia Borgia of New Jersey after she was arrested in 1921 for killing her brother with arsenic-laced chocolate pudding and was suspected of dispatching her in-laws in the same manner. She is believed to have been killed by Robert Zarinsky. After two meetings, Condon arranged the ransom drop, but the child did not turn up. A serial killer convicted for the murder of three women in New Jersey, and a near-fatal attack on a fourth, was charged Thursday in the murder of a 15-year-old girl who went missing from her . the undercover economist chapter summary. He was diagnosed with schizophrenia and spent the remainder of his life at Trenton Psychiatric Hospital, where he died in 2009 at the age of 88. After contacting Gary's friends, his mother learned that he did in fact spend time with them but left to go home at around 4:30. Zarinksy died at South Woods State Prison in Bridgeton in 2008 before he could be brought to trial in Durrua's murder. Charles Cullen, the nurse who administered fatal doses of drugs to at least 29 of his patients in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Authorities say she was strangled. One of the women managed to escape the house and alerted neighbors, and the Kallingers fled, Joseph shedding a bloodstained shirt that contained a major clue: a laundry label with his last name on it. It is believed that she attended a show the night before her body was found and she had stayed after to practice the piano. But Coppolino's vengeful ex-lover in New Jersey told investigators in Floridathat she believed Coppolinopoisoned Carmela with a powerful dose of a muscle relaxant because that's how he had planned to kill Farber tow years earlier, although she claims Coppolino ended up suffocating him to death. (Star-Ledger file photo). Thank you very much in advance. He eventually confessed to being responsible for several other murders -- in fact, earlier this year he pled guilty to raping and murdering two more teenage girls. This isn't just one infamous murder, but hundreds. In 1991, South Amboy single mother Michelle Lodzinskiclaimed her 5-year-old son Timothy Wiltsey had disappeared during a trip to a Sayreville carnival. Passaic County: LaFayette Bar & Grill murders. Less than two months later, Coppolinomarried wealthy divorcee Mary Gibson. Investigators wanted to test the body for traces of digoxin, Cullen's poison of choice. This Is What Life In New Jersey Looked Like In 1938. Mary Frances Creighton with her husband John, and their two children Ruth and John Jr. Creighton. in 1975, he was convicted of killing 17-year-old Rosemary Calandriello of Atlantic. Charles K. Landis, the founder of Vineland, was a progressive, but apparently didn't take kindly to criticism. Posted on June 7, 2022 by June 7, 2022 by Love New Jersey? Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). Justin Zaremba may be reached atjzaremba@njadvancemedia.com. Mercer County: TCNJ student Sigrid Stevenson. Despite improvements in forensic science and the use of video surveillance, numerous cold cases continue to stump investigators, in some cases, decades later. After the driver was shot, the glass shattered, Johnson fell forward and the passenger tried to steer the car and bring it to a stop before the crash. More:Neptune teen could face life in prison for 10-year-old's murder, More:Asbury Park Thanksgiving Eve killing: Eyewitness watched man die, More:Long Branch murder: Two dead in apparent murder-suicide, NJ murders: These are the six most notorious NJ serial killers, Neptune teen could face life in prison for 10-year-old's murder, Asbury Park Thanksgiving Eve killing: Eyewitness watched man die, Long Branch murder: Two dead in apparent murder-suicide, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. dr patel plastic surgeon oak brook. Michael Kallinger pleaded guilty to two counts of armed robbery, was eventually released from juvenile custody, moved out of state and changed his name. She was acquitted, and to escape the notoriety, she and her husband moved to Long Island, where they shared a home with another couple. The only physical trace of him investigators have found was his left sneaker, discovered on a beachalong the Delaware Bay. April Kauffman, a radio talk show host, was found shot to deathin the bedroom of the Linwood home she shared with her husband in May 2012. Several days later, his body was found bludgeoned in a parking lot just two blocks from the family's Atlantic City home. ]. Get the Asbury Park Press app today. To keep creating Police didn't discover the bodies until nearly a month later, by which time List had disappeared. Certainly, the Big Apple has experienced its share of criminals and crime (including the hideous crime against human decency that is Donald Trump's combover). (Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office). Let me know in the comments. The body of Princess Doe was found in a ravine at Cedar Ridge Cemetery in Blairstown in July 1982. When Edwards attempted to escape, Harris shot and killed him. The. Find NJ.com/Entertainment on Facebook. James Kauffman's medical license was suspended last weekpending the outcome of the criminal charges filed against him over the standoff. He was 68. Two years later, Coppolino and his wife Carmela moved to Florida, where Carmela died suddenly, justafterCoppolino increased his wife's insurance policy. Kuklinski, who later claimed he was a mafia hitman, was involved in all sorts of criminal activities, including operating a burglary ring. Chafic "Steve" Ezzeddine, 71, was killedin the Kenvil Diner, which he owned and operated for 30 years, on May 28, 2011. Coppolino served 12 years and was paroled in 1979, published a memoir called "The Crime That Never Was," about the case, and then completely dropped off the radar. A bust of John List was commissioned by 'America's Most Wanted' in 1989 for a segment on the 1971 murders. On the afternoon of January 13, 1996, nine-year-old Amber Hagerman and her five-year-old brother Ricky were playing, as they often did, in an abandoned grocery store parking lot in . (Star-Ledger file photo). (Ervin Hess). Landis was acquitted by reason of insanity, apparently the sort that doesn't require treatment, and was released though his wife did divorce him. Neulander was convicted of murder and sentenced to life in prison in 2003. He shot and killed a local newspaper editor who opposed him, but was found not guilty by reason of insanity. Edwards' wife smashed a window and screamed for help; a neighbor called police. Hedied in 2008 at the age of 67in the prison ward of St. Francis Medical Center in Trenton. Follow her on Twitter @vickihy. The mobster Dutch Schultz was the victim of a hit in Newark in 1935. During the investigation, robbery was developed as a possible motive for the crime since he had recently received money. Nancy Noga, 17, was found facedown in the snow on Jan. 12, 1999 in a ravine behind a mini-mall off Ernston Road in Sayreville, five days after she went missing.It took two days for her body to thaw before the medical examiner could perform an autopsy. If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation. (Newark Evening News). to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really (Noah K. Murray | Star-Ledger file photo), Carol Neulander was beaten to death in herCherry Hill home on Nov. 1, 1994, but it wasn't untilfour years later that police had enough evidence to arrest her husband Fred Neulander, a rabbi with a wandering eye, for murder. 2023 Advance Local Media LLC. Regardless, New Jerseys various law enforcement organizationswill never give up their investigations into these crimes byutilizing all of the resources at their disposal in order tosolve all of New Jerseys true crimes. He typically shot and stabbed his victims. The two North Bergen teens planned a trip to the Garden State Plaza on August 9th 1974. Postal Service worker in Ridgewood, had been fired in 1990 and was seeking revenge against his former supervisor, Carol Ott. His son, Charles Jr., was abducted from the family's East Amwell home on the evening of March 1st, 1932. Edward Wheeler Hall, of St. John the Evangelist Episcopal Church in New Brunswick, was found dead in a field from a gunshot wound alongside Eleanor Mills, whose throat was slit ear to ear, onSept. 16, 1922. Detectives re-create the positions of Rev. Joan Davis, 74, a political watchdog and outspoken gadfly, was found bludgeonedto death inside her Tudor-style home along Teaneck's Alpine Drive in August 2010. Mafia Hit List - Top New Jersey Mob Murders 9 years ago Scott Burnstein You are unauthorized to view this page. He was resentenced to life in prison, where he died in 2015. On Sept. 6, 1949, World War II veteran Howard Unruh killed 13 people. Arriving at her home, he slashed her to death with a samurai sword and shot and killed her boyfriend. Possibly one of the most famous unsolved mysteries in New Jersey history, you can see famed aviator Charles Lindbergh on the witness stand above. Kristen is a writer, editor, and social media maven who loves her state. Amanda Rae Carroll was last seen on May 1, 2000 in Flemington wearing a white shirt and blue jeans, according to the National Missing and Unidentified Persons database. Butcavage, who is currently in prison in Pennsylvania, has never been charged in connection with Himebaugh's disappearance. In 2000, a former congregant named Len Jenoff finally confessed tothe murder, saying Neulander had offered him $30,000 and told him his wife was "an enemy of Israel. Hamiltondied the next day in New York, and authorities in both New York and New Jerseyindicted Burr for murder, although he was not convicted. 1 LIST HERDE Home of the John List family in Westfield at 431 Hillside Avenue where 5 in the family were murdered 12/8/71. Cumberland County, N.J., Department of Corrections By Ed Shanahan Aug. 7, 2020 Zachary Latham. On Nov. 15, 1988, Joseph M. Harris, angered over a soured investment with Roy Edwards, donned a black ninja costume, black mask and gloves, and forced his way into Edwards' Montville home, where he sexually assaulted the man's wife and two young daughters. (Star-Ledger file photo). Rosario, who died several days later, is believed to have been assaulted on the property of Deola Farms, near the Italia Avenue residence. Carruth died seven months later from an infected abscess around the bullet wound. From 1980 to 2019, there were around 21,224 murders in New Jersey, based onProject: Cold Cases unsolved homicide statistics page. Which New Jersey crimes will you remember forever? On May 2, 1973, a car carrying Joanne Chesimard of the Black Liberation Army and two others waspulled over on the New Jersey Turnpike in East Brunswick by State Trooper James H. Harper, who noticed a broken taillight and called fellow trooper Werner Foerster for back-up. Find Inside Jersey on Facebook and Google+. Authorities say Bruce Santos, 26, was gunned down in an apparent robbery as he waited at a bus stop at Broad and Camp streets on his way home from work. (Mario Tama | Getty Images). Anyone with information on the stabbing cancall the Monmouth County Prosecutors Office tips line at 1-800-533-7443. While working as a nurse, Cullen killed at least 40 patients during his 16-year career. in 1975, he was convicted ofkilling 17-year-old Rosemary Calandriello of Atlantic Highlands, last seen in August 1969 on her way to the corner store. Investigatorshave described Himebaugh's disappearance as a "non-family abduction," and, in 2015,released a sketchof a man they described as a person of interest. TEANECK, N. J., Dec. 7The murder of a mother and her four children plunged this suburban Bergen County township and the communities that surround it into deep and incredulous shock today. Occasionally, these discussions focus onTrenton murders pictures, Trenton murders crime scene photos, and Trenton, New Jersey, murders autopsy photos, which are typically not publicly disclosed even when an investigation comes to an end. Here are the 21 most notorious murders, crime sprees and serial killers in New Jersey history. (Patti Sapone | NJ Advance Media). Workers remove the urn continaing the ashes of Larry Dean, believed to be one of Charles Cullen's murder victims, from his grave in Phillipsburg in 2004. Bestselling true crime writer Joe McGinniss turned the tale into "Blind Faith," which became a TV movie starring Robert Urich and Johnny Galecki. Rosados remains were later found along the Delaware River and positively identified. However, according to FBI Uniform Crime Reports from prior years, Mercer County has had extremely few homicides, and their crime patterns reflect this. A neighborhood youngster saw her get into a car with two men. While he admitted his extramarital affairs, he still denies arranging his wife's murder. He managed to evade the police for 18 years, taking on a new identity and even remarrying. He was sentenced to life in prison in 2006. Rev. Wendy Wolin, 7, was fatally stabbed in 1966 as she walked down the street in Elizabeth in broad daylight, but no one was ever charged with her murder despitean extensive investigation. Authorities have said the sketch resembled Thomas Butcavage, a convicted sex offender who first became associated with the case in 1993. Odds are youll see a couple of names on the list of all murders in New Jersey or list of murders in Jersey that at least seem familiar. You'll receive your first newsletter soon! Police suspected Hall's older and wealthier wife, Frances Stevens Hall, but she wasn't indicted until a local hog farmer called the Pig Woman came forward with claims that she witnessed the soon-to-be-widow and her brother confronting Hall and Mills that day. Clues. Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement, Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (each updated 1/26/2023). Her body was discovered in Oct. 1990 bya grouse hunter about 40 yards off of Old Mine Road in Sandyston. (Essex County Prosecutor's Office). Even if you are not from or living in New Jersey, you may recognize at least one of the most famous New Jersey murders, if not more. In summary, violent crime in New Jersey in 2019 affected roughly 207 individuals per 100,000 inhabitants, including assault, rape, burglary, and homicide. Uri Carruth, editor of the weekly Vineland Independent, routinely took issue with Landis' imperiousness, and on March, 20, 1875, made their feud personal, publishing an editorial that didn't name Landis but suggested a prominent townsperson was considering committing his wife to an insane asylum. Crime scene photos are usually graphic in nature, but are used in order to show the jury every aspect of the crime. Anyone with information about this case can contact the Ocean County Prosecutors Office, Major Crime Unit at 732-929-4760 or Detective Sgt. After the suitcases turned up in the Chesapeake, investigators foundE-ZPass records of McGuire's car at a Delaware toll (which she tried to remove from her account history) and matched the luggage with a set she had in her basement. His body was found two months later near the Lindbergh home. the Murderpedia project stay alive. Her blue Toyota Corolla was also unaccounted for, but later located in Lakewood. That year, New Jersey legislators passed Megan's Law, while a national version was signed into law in 1996. Three people were shot and killed at Lafayette Bar & Grill on East 18th Street in Paterson on June 17, 1966 James Oliver, Fred Nauyoks and Hazel Tanis. YouTubes privacy policy is available here and YouTubes terms of service is available here. (Alexandra Pais | For NJ Advance Media). Anyone with information about Amanda Rae Carroll's disappearance can contact Raritan Township Police Department at 908-782-8889. The case remains unsolved nearly 20 years after the little. The so-called 'Pig Lady' testifies at the 1926 trial of Frances Stevens Hall in the murder of her husband and his mistress. He shot and killed a local newspaper editor who opposed him, but was found not guilty by reason of insanity. Harris, wearing a gas mask and a bulletproof vest, and armed with a machine gun, a samurai sword, hand grenades and homemade bombs, eventually surrendered. All rights reserved (About Us). The body of 25 year old Sigrid Stevenson was found on the main stage of the music hall (shown above), beaten and bloody. Biegenwald was sentenced to die by lethal injection for the murder of Olesiewicz, but the state Supreme Court overturned the death sentence twice. Investigators have interviewed more than 160 people in connection with Suarez's. During a massive search for the missing child, law enforcement officers ascertained that there were three sex offenders Joseph Cifelli, Jesse Timmendequas, then 36, and Brian Jenin living across the street from the Kanka family. Marshall was convicted of murder in 1986 and sentenced to death by lethal injection, but it was overturned in 2004 because of ineffective legal counsel during the death penalty phase. Anonymous tips can be submitted via the prosecutor's office information center. In one of the nation's earliest shooting rampages (it was dubbed the "Walk of Death"), World War II veteran Howard Unruh sprayed a Camden neighborhood with gunfire on the morning of Sept. 6, 1949, killing 13 people in the space of 20 minutes. Which of these stories was most disturbing? She and the other husband started an affair, and soon after the man's wifedied after drinking arsenic-tainted milk. John List, bottom left, murdered his entire family in Westfield and disappeared in 1971. 1. In 1975, Robert Zarinsky of Linden was brought in for the 1969 murder of 17-year-old Rosemary Calandriello. And yet Creighton might have escaped notice had a packet of newspaper clippings about the Newark poisonings not found its way to investigators on Long Island. 23 Rare Photos Taken In New Jersey During The Great Depression. John List, a failing financial planner, meticulously planned every detail of the murder of his wife, three children and mother-in-law, down to his request that that they be cremated to keep costs low. Richard Biegenwald is responsible for at least six murders and potentially up to eight. Authorities described the suspect as a man in his 20s with dreadlocks. Based on the unsolved homicide statistics webpage on Project: Cold Cases website, there are currently around 6,546 New Jersey cold cases, a much smaller number than the state had previously, owing to law enforcement efforts and improvements in DNA technology. SERIAL killer John List murdered his entire family and went on the run for 18 years after erasing himself from every photo in the house. Harris was part of a lawsuit refuting the constitutionality of the state's death penalty, arguing that it was biased against blacks, but in 1996, he died in his cell two days before a hearing in front of the New Jersey Supreme Court. "OCPOs Cold Case Unit investigators serve as advocates for victims in unsolved cases regardless of how much time has passed, working to bring peace to the loved ones of an individual who was senselessly killed or is missing.".